VPN through Tor or Tor through VPN?

Tor vs. VPN

TOR Over VPN & VPN Over TOR: Which is Better?
The former will give you no benefit over using only VPN, but it will be slower. Because a chance of VPN operators logging activity always exists, my own opinion is that if your threat model requires that you hide your Tor traffic from your ISP, then it's best to not use that ISP at all. If you find VPN provides with Multi-hop routing, that much the better. Tor is slower but provides complete anonymity. Also, your VPN would only be able to see that you are connecting to TOR nodes and that you are sending encrypted data. R with a rock solid VPN. Agreed, however does the increased us of Mifi devices complicate things further for home use?

VPN To Tor


If logs are kept, then the traffic can easily be correlated back to your real IP. Again going back to the Harvard bomb threat, if he had used a VPN that logged his traffic, the police could have gone to all the VPN providers that were connected to the network at the time and asked for any logs with a court order and a VPN company won't shut down for you. Because a chance of VPN operators logging activity always exists, my own opinion is that if your threat model requires that you hide your Tor traffic from your ISP, then it's best to not use that ISP at all.

Go find some public WiFi though this is a tip that we should heed whenever a high degree of anonymity is desired. If you do insist on routing Tor through your VPN, then the setup is fairly easy. This configuration, to me, brings a greater degree of advantage to running both Tor and a VPN than the previous configuration does.

Routing your traffic through Tor to your VPN has the major benefit of hiding traffic from malicious exit nodes. Because traffic is encrypted with the VPN before entering the Tor network, and because it is decrypted after leaving the Tor network, any exit relays that are snooping your traffic will see nothing but noise. Posted 26 October - I see this point being made that VPN should be running over Tor but if it is the case that no logs are kept by the VPN, then why is it necessary?

Assuming that logs of IP addresses are not kept, why should running Tor be necessary so that the VPN server only sees the Tor exit node? Posted 04 February - Could you please explain the technical side of your VPN over Tor solution? Also, would that method work in case the whole system traffic is to be torified, e. Posted 12 March - It is a layer of anonyimity "by design" where trust on us is not necessary.

The VPN server needs to check whether an account is on premium status in order to allow the connection but does not keep any information about any account, it queries for authorization a backend server.

We recommend NOT to put information in your account data that can be exploited to disclose your identity. As long as we don't know who you are, we can't tell anybody who you are. The AirVPN system, if used correctly, is designed to defeat an adversary that has up to the following abilities please note that this is a very harsh scenario, in most cases the following steps are required only in countries controlled by repressive regimes: Finally this is not our competence, but obviously highly recommended the customer should add a further encryption layer to protect her packets payload once they get out of our servers trivial example, use GnuPG for e-mails in case the payload could be exploited for example by a second adversary, unrelated to the first, that monitors the line of the final recipient to disclose the customer's identity.

An adversary with superior abilities may not be defeated by the above setup. The second kind of adversary renders the anonymity layer outside the victim's hardware irrelevant. The global adversary theoretically can never be defeated on the Internet. Luckily, the very existance of the global adversary an adversary with the ability to monitor, store, analyze and correlate all the connections in the world continuously is highly debatable. Here, we will assume that Alice and Bob are communicating via bittorrent.

By taking advantage of the fact that Tor only provides a secure TCP connection, Alice is then tricked into revealing her actual identity. One of the most important features one should look for when shopping for VPN services is variable multi-hop capabilities. Here, one has the opportunity to bounce his encrypted traffic across multiple networks, further reducing the possibility that traffic-analysis based attacks would be successful.

Additionally, one can, at the drop of a hat, choose a different multi-hop path for his traffic. Back to Privacy Guides.


How can the answer be improved?Tell us how. Although in many ways very different, both VPN and the Tor anonymity network use encrypted proxy connections in order to hide users’ identities (VPN is useful for much more than this, but privacy is a core feature of the technology). We also have an expanded version of this article which examines. How do I confirm my data data passes through VPN first before it enters the first Tor entry server? While using VPN alone, I can go to a webstie to display my IP, so that I know when I have switched VPN of or not.